ORISSA CIC EMBARASSES THE STATE BY SUSPECTED SELF-GLORIFICATION

Subhas Chandra Pattanayak

Chief Information Commission D.N.Padhi, who left IAS in last leg to grab the post of Chief Information Commission of Orissa has embarrassed the State by projecting himself in the media as the best amongst the Country’s CICs when in fact the source cited vehemently rejects this claim.

A combine of Orissa’s RTI activists has in a memorandum to the Governor demanded for action against Padhi under Section 17 of RTI Act, 2005, even as Public Cause Research Foundation (PCRF), the organization on whose survey the Orissa Information Commission has claimed Padhi to have topped the ranking has published a clarification in its website that no such determination has yet been made.

IAS officers of Orissa cadre are generally marked for their eagerness to grab prize posts that would give them power, pay package and luxury in their post retirement days. Padhi’s emergence as CIC, Orissa may be cited as an instance. But rash projection of self as the best in the lot using the name of any private organization is not always the case with every ex-IAS officer.

ic siteIt is more intriguing that when the propaganda of Padhi topping the ranking amongst CICs published in Orissa media was found to have flowed from a press release by Orissa Information Commission, RTI activists having objected to it on basis of their inquiry with PCRF, the said press release has been deleted from the site. Copy of the site’s concerned page shows that the Press Release No.1 is wiped out.

Shouldn’t the Information Commission come forward with the correct information?

Orissa Governor Urged Upon By ‘Reporters Without Borders’ To Save Journalist Laxman Choudhury From Cooked Up Cases

Chief Minister Navin Patnaik sitting nonchalant over Orissa scribes’ request to save Sambad’s rural reporter Laxman Choudhury from false cases cooked up by the Police, an international body of reporters, Reporters without Borders, has expressed deep concern over havoc wrecked on Freedom of press in Orissa and has, in a communication addressed to the Governor of the State, urged upon him to rise to the occasion.

We reproduce the communication:

H.E. Murlidhar Chandrakant Bhandare
Governor of Orissa
Raj Bhawan
Bhubaneswar 751 008
Orissa

Paris, 6 November 2009

Subject: Call for Laxman Choudhury’s release

Dear Governor,

Reporters Without Borders, an organisation that defends press freedom worldwide, would like to share with you its deep concern about the fate of reporter Laxman Choudhury of the daily newspaper Sambad, who was arrested on 20 September.

As you probably know, Mr. Choudhury was charged with sedition after being found in possession of Maoist leaflets. He is now waiting to appear before the Orissa high court.

He had received the leaflets like a dozen other journalists. The Maoists send their press releases and leaflets to reporters on a regular basis. They constitute news material and receiving them can under no circumstances be regarded as evidence of Maoist links. For these reasons, we consider that Mr. Choudhury’s arrest by the Gajapati police is arbitrary and unjustifiable, and violates the Indian constitution.

We are afraid he may have been the victim of an act of revenge by local authorities who were alarmed by his revelations. Orissa Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik promised to a delegation of four journalists that he would order an investigation into the allegations that Mr. Choudhury’s arrest was an act of revenge. But since then we have received no information about this investigation or how far it has advanced.

As the Orissa high court has not issued any ruling in this case, we urge you to use your constitutional authority to ensure that the petition is taken up by the court promptly so that Mr. Choudhury can be released.

I thank you in advance for the attention you give to this request.

Respectfully,
Jean-François Julliard
Secretary-General

Attack on Journalists Continues In Orissa….

PRASANTA PATNAIK’S CLARION CALL FOR UNITED ACTION BY THE JOURNALISTS

Eminent Journalist Prasanta Patnaik has given a clarion call to journalists of Orissa to start united action against miscreants that play havoc with Freedom of Press.

He writes thus:

While our journalist friend from Mohana, Laxman Chaudhury is languishing in jail because of a conspiracy hatched by some unscrupulous policemen who have branded him as an associate of Naxals, another journalist friend Jagannath Bastia of Puri, representing oddest Oriya daily Samaj, has become a victim of severe assault by anti-socials for exposing the Soddy deals of land grabbers and politicians in Puri. Bastia was also a well known environmentalist who was fighting since last few years to save the environment of Holy City of Puri and its world famous golden beach.

Earlier two scribes Sriharsha Mishra and Kiran Mishra , representing AAROMBH daily published from Bhubaneswar were subjected to atrocious behaviour of Collector, Jharsuguda while collecting information about death of farmers. Sriharsha was injured when the employees of the Collectorate used force to physically throw him out from the Collector’s chamber on receiving instructions from the Collector. Though a FIR was filed with Jharsuguda police against the Collector by aggrieved Mr Mishra, the police preferred to keep quiet. Moreover the matter was also reported in AAROMV elaborately, but failed to evoke no response from the Government, newspaper editors and journalist organisation.

Such dangerous trend of attack on journalists by the police, administrative officers, politicians and anti-socials has certainly posed a serious threat to our profession as well as to the lives and properties of journalists who are trying to expose the anti-people activities of officials, politicians and vested interests.

I personally feel that such attack on media and media persons would increase day by day if we will not give an united fight against such vested interests involved in anti-people activities and working against the interests of the State and the country to achieve their personal goals.

I would therefore request all the media persons, people who believe in free and independent media and prosperity of the State to join hands together to fight against such heinous forces in all spheres.

x x x x x x x x

Expecting your valued suggestions at the earliest and thanking you,
Prasanta Patnaik,
5RF/5, UNIT-3, M.G. MARG,
BHUBANESWAR-751001.
e-mail: patnaikprasanta@gmail.com

ATTACK ON PRESS CONTINUES IN ORISSA: RULING PARTY STALWART NAMED IN FIR


Subhas Chandra Pattanayak

Severely injured Jagannath Bastia, Puri Correspondent of The Samaj, in his FIR on 6th before being shifted to a Bhubaneswar Hospital for bone fracture repair, has named ruling party stalwart Maheswar Mohany, a former Speaker and sitting member of Orissa Legislative Assembly as the instigator of the attempt to murder him. The motive behind the murderous assault, that has caused multiple bone fractures in his leg and hands, was set to avenge exposure of land scam in the pilgrimage city, in which, Mohanty was allegedly the facilitator.

Mohanty has instantly refuted the allegation stating that the injured scribe might have acquiesced in to pressure from his political rivals to implicate him falsely in the FIR.

Two unidentified goons attacked Bastia at 11.15 in the night on 5th while he was returning to his home from the bureau office of Samaj at Puri. It was an unprovoked attack, designed to murder him. He was saved, he says, by catching hold of the stick before it could hit his head.

Samaj editor Sarat Mishra has rushed a request to Chief Minister Navin Patnaik to wake up the Police into action against the assailants even as all the trade unions of journalists have condemned the dastardly act and have expressed shock over continuous attack on Press under the present regime.

WHY IS NAVIN PATNAIK SHYING AT CBI?


Subhas Chandra Pattanayak

Former secretary of National Union of Journalists, India, Sri Balbir Punj, who presently represents Orissa in the Rajyasabha, has demanded an inquiry by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) into the massive mining scam perpetrated and going on in Orissa under the reign of Navin Patnaik.

Punj, in his spot study of the scam in Keonjhar district, had led a team of BJP leaders that comprised also his colleague in Parliament, Sri Chandan Mitra, who like him is a Journalist turned politician with right wing attire.

The team made a spot estimation of loot of ores at Kashia, Chormaldar, Loidapada and Regudi where ESSEL, OMC and RBTL are nefariously involved and came out with facts too revealing to be refuted.

Not the Vigilance police that works under Navin Patnaik, but the CBI that runs not under Navin Patnaik should be asked to investigate so that the truth of loot may not be stopped from coming out, declared the BJP leaders.

But to Navin Patnaik, this is nothing but a political notoriety resorted to by BJP.

Punj and Mitra have gone to the spot and have made the allegation on the basis of what they have seen on the spot. Chief Minister Navin Patnaik has never visited the spot so far.

He obviously uses the State Vigilance in matter of the loot. The loot is so very discernible that the Vigilance Police is not able to say that there is no loot.

Now that admittedly there is loot, Navin should confess that in his regime the loot has occurred. But he has not done it so far.

As time passes, he looks murkier.

If he is to depend upon hearsay about the occurrence and / or non-occurrence of the loot, why should he not depend upon the CBI than the State Vigilance to know what really has happened?

The matter is so critical but delicate, even if the State Vigilance Police would act honestly and bring out details of the loot and the looters, people would sure look at that askance.

Therefore it is true that the Chief Minister by not accepting the demands for the inquiry by CBI, is dragging the State Vigilance to a state of forfeiture of its credibility.

Will the CM amend himself and entrust the investigation to CBI as demanded by Punj and Mitra?

ORISSA ADMINISTRATION: WHEN THE GOVERNOR IS ATTACKED THE GOVERNMENT KEEPS MUM!

Subhas Chandra Pattanayak

Orissa government is keeping mum when Amarikatha, a daily broadsheet preferred by the administration to spread official advertisements, has alleged that the Governor of the State has succumbed to bribe and bureaucratic design in appointing the Vice-Chancellor of Orissa University of Agriculture and Technology (OUAT), Bhubaneswar for a fresh term in stark disregards to the UGC norms.

The paper has raised serious allegations against the conduct of the VC. According to it, D. P. Roy is not the real name of the VC. He was earlier Sambeta Devi Prasanna Rao, a compartmentally passed matriculate, who had entered into Agriculture course by using an allegedly fake intermediate certificate in science and in BSc (Agiculture), had got 14 F grade markings. It has alleged that for such poor result in the Bachelor level, he was refused admission to Masters in Agriculture in OUAT. While somehow doing his Masters at Kolkata, he changed his name to the present one by virtue of an affidavit. He had joined, the paper has further alleged, as an agriculture supervisor under the government, but could eventually succeed in equating this post with that of an Associate Professor and has cultivated an impression as a scholar by using others’ works through plagiarism. His first term as VC was marked for crores of rupees corruption about which allegations are sent to President Mrs. Prativa Patil, the paper has reported in its top-prioritized front page story on November 3, wherein it has alleged that despite being aware of this, the Governor has reappointed Roy as the second term VC obviously under suspected influence of corruption in oblivion of restriction imposed by UGC on reappointment of one person as VC in any university for two consecutive terms.

These allegations are grave in nature inasmuch as a VC of an University has been projected as a miscreant and more seriously, the Governor of the State, whom people have been showing love and respect, has been dragged into a controversial condition.

But astonishingly the VC as well as the State Government have kept mum over the report.

JOURNALISTS OF BHUBANESWAR PAY EPITAPHIC TRIBUTES TO GOPAL MISHRA

There are different organizations of Journalists stationed at Bhubaneswar. But they all were united on Tuesday evening to pay epitaphic tributes to deeply mourned Gopal Misra, who passed away in the evening of Sunday and whose cremation, witnessed by many a luminaries of Orissa, was performed at Swargadwara, the classic gateway to the abode of the gods, on the beach of Mahodadhi, wrongfully known as Bay of Bengal, at Puri, on Monday.

condolence meetingThe condolence meeting was held in the auditorium of the Department of Information with eminent journalist Barendrakrishna Dhal in the Chair. Under request of the scribes present, senior journalists Ramahari Mishra, Subhas Chandra Pattanayak, Rabi Das and Sarat Das were on the dais when Ramahari Mishra coordinated the event.

Ramesh Chandra Mohanty initiated the obituary when Barendrakrushna Dhal dwelt on how suave but strong was Mishra in his mission all through his life as a journalist. There was a time spanning at least two decades in the last century when he was regarded as the reigning luminary in Orissa media, but there was not a single moment, even then, when he had no time to come to the needs of the newcomers to the profession, he said.

Subhas Chandra Pattanayak focused on the professionalism he personified. Recalling his contributions to putting on records Chakradhar Mohapatra’s well researched determination of Orissa being the real birthplace of Buddha as well as Kavichandra Kalicharan Pattanayak’s meticulous endeavors to obtain recognition of Odissi as a classical dance, he said that Gopal Mishra was so sharp and quick in reporting critical issues by locating its crux as cautiously as consciously that for ever he would remain not only a poll star to follow but also a professional to imitate.

Rabi Das recalled Gopal Babu as a trendsetter in pro-people journalism even as to Sarat Das, were Mishra not there to organize his stay at Bhubaneswar in the initial days of his posting, he perhaps could not have ascended up to the bureau chief position of PTI in Orissa. This eagerness to help newcomer journalists in getting settled was a distinct part of Mishra’s way of life, he said.

the daisRamahari Mishra recalled his association with Gopal Babu prior to and after his joining Amrit Bazar Patrika. He cited instances to show how he was regarded as unquestionable as a journalist. He said that the sad demise would always give the journalists of Orissa a feeling of loss.

Prasanta Patnaik deeply mourned the sad demise. To him, Mishra was a man in whom journalism had blossomed into dignity. Commitment to profession and devotion to democracy had created the distinction that Mishra had personified, he said, while making specific suggestions on how the scribes of Orissa may make the bereavement bearable to the family of the late doyen.

Bimal Krushna Bhanj and Akshaya Pati described how the entire media community has been drowned in grief due to the sudden demise that has created a void hard to be filled up, when from his chair in the audience, Pradyumna Mohanty expressed deep dismay over failure of the ministers of the incumbent government in physically paying last respect gopal mishra last journeyto the departed scribe who till breathing his last was active in the fourth estate of democracy.

(Gopal Mishra’s last contribution as a columnist, published in the daily Sambad at the end of the night he passed away, was speakingly critical of the style of administration of the Orissa Ministry that was, on the one hand, irresponsive to SOS cries of the farmers, but on the other hand, over eager to serve the multi-national corporations. This perhaps explains the absence of Orissa ministers from paying individual and / or collective respect to the departed scribe who by choice had preferred this profession to serve the people.)

The former and founder Mayor of Bhubaneswar Municipal Corporation, Dr. Jagannath Mohapatra recalled the unique joie de vivre that Mishra personified despite his being in his entirety a dedicated sentinel of the State.

A close relation of Mishra, R.N.Dash, who happens to be the Secretary of the Information Department, recalled from his personal memories how affectionate was Gopal babu and how averse was he to falsehood and hypocrisy.

Gopal Mishra Breathed His Last: Lost is a Jewel of Journalism

Subhas Chandra Pattanayak

Orissa is snatched off her jewel in journalism as Gopal Mishra breathed his last this evening in a private but referral Hospital in Bhubaneswar.

Minimum ten years senior to me in this profession, he was very sharp and precise in application of his mind to every burning issue and noteworthy event of Orissa, but was always a man with a perfect sense of proportion.

Most dignified in personal dealings, he was embodiment of magnanimity that journalism stands for.

We worked together for trade union rights of working journalists and also parted our ways on difference in perception of labour activism; but despite this, he was such a person that this difference had never affected our mutual friendship.

His journalism was addressed to Orissa’s development. But dovetailed with it was Orissa’s culture.

It is, at the moment, impossible to find another Gopal Mishra in Orissa.

Journalism has lost an invaluable jewel.

Journalist Gopal Mishra passes away

Eminent journalist Gopal Mishra is no more, but the power and conviction of his pen that touched millions of Oriyas shall be always missed.

A journalist and columnist of national repute, Mr Mishra had served the collective conscience of the country for over 50 years. For his invaluable contributions, he was bestowed with many prestigious awards and recognition during his lifetime, including “Sambadika Gourab” and “Udaynath Sarangi Award”.

Orissamatters deeply mourns the great and irreparable loss, and conveys heartfelt condolence to his bereaved family members and to his beloved readers.

SUICIDE OR EMANCIPATION?

Subhas Chandra Pattanayak

Suicide can be defined as the extreme form of passive revolt against unconquerable oppression. Therefore the ever-increasing numbers of farmers’ suicide suggest that they are under such oppression, which seems to them as unconquerable.

When an individual commits suicide it may be attributed to unconquerable oppression perpetrated upon him or her by another individual or group of individuals. But when a class of people commits suicide, the oppressor cannot but be the State.

State is a power that becomes the instrument of oppression only when it falls in the hands of persons who possess it not by virtue of self-less sacrifice for the people but by being the facilitators of private industry. State then runs by State terrorism.

As far as Orissa is concerned, the State-power lies in the hands of the Prime Minister Man Mohan Singh at the center and Chief Minister Navin Patnaik in the State.

None of these two has any record of sacrifice for the people. But both of them are facilitators of private industry even of foreign origin and foreign interest. No wonder, with them at the helms of affairs, the farmers have been committing suicide in ever-increasing numbers.

Instead of embracing suicidal death as the extreme form of passive revolt against oppression, whosoever oppose oppression actively, these two functionaries notwithstanding their difference in political attires, become one in condemning them as extremists, terrorists or Naxals and unleash State terrorism to push them into homicidal deaths.

The syndrome is so serious that a man like K.P.S.Gill who is known as an eager exterminator of extremists / insurgents in the country has in a recent interview to Tehelka disapproved “Operation Green Hunt” – the latest form of State terrorism – being unleashed against people that are considered active voice of the oppressed.

It is time, all of the Indians that are not exploiters, must get united to decide as to which method of revolt against oppression is desirable: passive revolt that leads to suicide or active revolt that ensures emancipation.

Emancipation is possible only when plutocracy that has replaced democracy is removed.